While the topic of iPhone photography may be hotly debated as to whether it is “real” photography, or art, surely iPod photography must receive more scorn. While the iPhone camera ranges from 5 to 8 megapixels (depending on the model), the iPod Touch 4g comes in at around .9 megapixel. (yes, a hair under 1 megapixel.) Many will call the camera crap, or a toy. Of course compared to “real” cameras, it is. But I still think a person can get a nice arty photo from an iPod Touch 4g, especially with one of the many funky photo apps that are available for the iPhone & iPod.
Ever since I was a kid, I’ve always been inspired by old photographs. I fondly recall looking through a shoebox full of old photos at my Grandmother’s when I was a young child. They seemed oddly different compared to the photos my parents took. Mostly black & white, many shot on old Brownie cameras whose lenses had some distortion or blur on the edges. Some with light leaks that streaked across parts of the image. And some tin types. The tin types were especially interesting. Dark & mysterious even. Later in college photo history courses, I learned more about the very early days of photography, and was drawn in even more to that look and feel.

View from the Window at Le Gras, Joseph Nicéphore Niépce - 1826
This morning I recalled some of the photographs from my photo history courses. La cour du domaine du Gras (View from the Window at Le Gras) by Joseph Nicéphore Niépce came to mind. This image was the first successful permanent photograph. It was created using a camera obscura on a roughly 8″ x 10″ sheet of pewter, coated with Bitumen of Judea.
As the use of silver nitrate began to be used in photography, image quality improved. Hand coated film plates always had their own unique qualities, and “perfection” was literally in the hands of the artist. As the process became mechanized, and mass produced, it seemed we strived for a more “perfect” image in an attempt to capture a more accurate sense of reality.
For me, this first photographic image by Niépce creates a more artistic feel than a sharp photograph would. It carries much more emotional energy as well. It is mysterious, dreamlike, and perhaps holds a touch of darkness to it.

The Guardian - by Jim Sincock (shot on iPod Touch, with the Hipstamatic app)
The image reminds me of the quality of some of the photos I’ve taken with my iPod Touch using the Hipstamatic app. Well, the iPod obviously does a bit better job with sharpness and tonal range. (Although, in low light situations, and depending on the “film” used, I have seen iPod photos get almost as grainy as Niépce’s photo above, with only a slightly better tonal range.) And while the iPod camera is not the first digital camera, it’s low quality is vaguely reminiscent of the first photo process.
Art has always been subjective. It took a long time before photography was accepted as art, and it was no different when the digital photo age began. And while I also drool over the new digital camera gear that is coming out, I still like the simple, rougher feel that I get with my silly little iPod Touch camera. If had taken this image with a sharp lens on a high megapixel camera, I’m certain I’d find it less appealing than this shot from my iPod. Not to say that would be true with every image, as there are many times I wish one of my iPod photos had been taken on a better camera.
Perhaps some day I’ll move up to the higher resolution iPhone for my “pocket camera”, but for now I enjoy the high tech, low res iPod Touch for fast and fun shots. Some day I also intend on going back to some of the old photo processes with my 4×5 cameras, but that is a different story.
If you came to this post wondering if the iPod Touch is worth it for photographs, well, it just depends on your needs. I think it is suitable for the “arty” little shots I take with it. I’ve printed images to 5″ x 5″ on smooth inkjet watercolor paper, and the images looked fine. I also feel it is okay for basic shots where you need to document something that doesn’t require a high resolution. I’ve taken a couple farming workshops and it was great for snapping photos of how greenhouses where set up, and other details. Plus I could type notes in the notepad, or even take a fairly decent quality video. Not bad for an MP3 player!